Getting a handle on any major rock band is at least as easy as herding cats. But that hasn’t stopped the production of books purporting to provide the “real story.” Three recent publications illustrate three very different ways of nabbing their elusive quarry. In Smoke On The Water: The Deep Purple Story (E.C.W.), Dave Thompson assembles publicly available material and appears to make a story by arranging the basic factoids about the group in chronological order. Although Pat Gilbert also uses some previously published interviews in Passion Is A Fashion: The Real Story Of The Clash (DaCapo), his grasp of that band goes far beyond stale stuff. Gilbert richly provides his own interviews with members of The Clash and many of their key collaborators and co-conspirators. His book is a model for all band bios, full of his own and others’ insights, and refreshingly re-plete with contrasting perspectives. Clinton Heylin takes a radically different ap-proach, presenting re-views and interviews published during the life of the band in All Yesterday’s Parties: The Velvet Under-ground In Print 1966-1971 (DaCapo). VU began at the same moment as rock criticism, and the authors here, all of whom genuflect, are a who’s who of early rock crits, including Richard Goldstein, Lenny Kaye, Lester Bangs, Ben Edmonds, and Danny Goldberg.
- Read more: Three Sides To Every Story
Tags: